« How Can I Keep From Singing? | Main | Saturday, Freezing Rain »

14 January 2005 — Mac Zealot (11)

Apple announced new products Tuesday. I believe that you should consider one of these — the Mac mini — when you're ready to purchase your next computer.

Here's why:

The Mac mini is small. It's inexpensive. It sports modest technology, but ships with a good selection of consumer software. And more can be downloaded for free. Best of all: this computer is presently free from the scourge of viruses, adware, spyware, and popup ads.


"We've got computer problems," Jeff told me when I got to work this morning.

I panicked. "What do you mean?"

"Not here at work," he said. "At home. I signed up for DSL so that Nick would be willing to watch our dogs when we're out of town. Last night I went to hook it up and found that my computer was infested with spyware. I tried to remove most of it, but when I did, the thing locked up. It won't even boot now. It tries to, but then Windows 98 gives me some stupid error."

"Ugh," I thought. "Windows 98."

(Seriously, folks: Windows 98 is antiquated. It's an unstable, insecure operating system. If your computer is running Windows 98, you need to upgrade your operating system, or your computer, or both.)

"You know," I said to Jeff, my voice trailing off — I was unsure I wanted to say what I was about to say. "You know, Apple just released a new cheap Macintosh. Macs don't have problems with spyware yet."

There. I'd said it. After two years of resisting, plunged back into pool of Mac zealotry.

The water's fine, thank you very much.


I used to be a Mac zealot. In the mid-nineties, I extolled the virtues of Apple computers at every opportunity. My efforts were for naught, I fear; I never convinced a single person to buy a Mac.

Eventually, I left the world of Macintosh and bought a PC. I was a PC user for five years before I wandered back to Apple. I've gradually rid myself of PCs so that now I am a Mac-only man once again.

I've resisted the urge to resume the role of Mac zealot, though. Nobody likes a zealot. What's more, I believe that, in general, it doesn't matter which computer platform you use. You can get things done with a Mac, with a Linux-based PC, or with a Windows-based PC. The key is to use what works best for you.

For today only, I'm going to remove all restraint and enter full zealotry mode.


Over the past year, I've watched as my friends, family, and customers have become increasingly frustrated with their PCs. The spectre of adware and spyware haunts Windows-based machines. Popup ads are everywhere. Viruses attack without warning, and attack hard. (See my Rough Guide to Removing Spyware.) Day-to-day tasks are more challenging than they need to be for the average user: setting up a new printer or adding an internet connection or burning a CD are all non-obvious tasks. (By non-obvious, I mean they do not pass the "Mom test" — could a majority of middle-aged women — or men — accomplish a specific task without help?)

The Macintosh operating system is not subject to adware or spyware. Popup ads are nonexistent. There are no Mac viruses. Day-to-day tasks are generally fairly obvious and easy to complete. (Note that many people, including myself, believe that the lack of spyware, etc. on Macs is largely due to the fact that so few people use the platform. If huge waves of people moved to Mac, problems would likely follow. For now, though, Mac users lead charmed lives.)

I'm not claiming that Macs are perfect. Far from it. They're painfully slow when working with large quantities of files. It takes forever to burn a CD (about four times as long as on a PC with similar equipment). Sometimes the designers have been too clever by half, going so far as to hide features for the sake of a sleek interface. Default models still ship with half as much RAM as is practical. But overall these quibbles are minor.

Using the Macintosh operating system may not be a joy, but it's pleasant. It's never a chore. In comparison, using Windows is often tedious. And when it's broken — from viruses or spyware or just plain malfunctioning software — using Windows is downright frustrating. ("I broke my keyboard last night," Jeff told me today. "I hit the damn thing, I was so angry.")


I recently placed a computer order for a client. We ordered two Dell desktops at $611 each. Each of these machines had the following specs:

2.4ghz Celeron processor
256mb RAM
40gb hard drive
CD-burner
Microsoft Office Basic
Mouse and keyboard
No monitor

How does this compare to the new Mac mini? For $499 one could order a Mac mini with the following specs:

1.25ghz g4 (roughly equivelant to a 1.8ghz Celeron)
256mb RAM
40gb hard drive
CD-burner/DVD combo drive
Appleworks & iLife
No mouse or keyboard
No monitor

The two primary differences between these machines — other than the presence of a mouse and keyboard — are processor speed and software package. I cannot speak as to the perceived speed difference between the two processors. I believe the Dell would seem faster, but not by much. The Dell also includes Microsoft Office Basic (Word, Excel, Powerpoint), while the Mac does not. However, the Mac includes AppleWorks — a basic productivity suite with Microsoft-compatible word processor, spreadsheet, etc. — and iLife, a suite of programs designed for home use. These programs include iTunes (for managing your music library), iPhoto (for managing your digital photos), and iMovie (for editing film from your camcorder).

The Mac has a definite advantage when it comes to two applications that the typical user needs most: web browser and e-mail. The default Apple Mail application is a sleek e-mail client that is easier to use then Microsoft Outlook Express, and that includes a brilliant search feature. And Safari, Apple's web browser, is in a completely different class than Microsoft's aging behemoth, Internet Explorer. Safari is fast, secure, and easy to use. Its features tabbed browsing, built-in google search, and automatic popup blocking.

With the $112 you might save by buying the Mac mini instead of the Dell, you could purchase a mouse and keyboard (if you don't have one from your old computer), purchase more RAM or a bigger hard drive, or, better yet, pay $8 or $10 or $12 each for several little Mac programs that make life easier. (More on these next week, perhaps.)

I would nearly always recommend a Mac over a Windows-based machine for the average user. There are a few cases for which a Macintosh may not be right for you:

  1. Your business depends upon a specialized application that is PC only.
  2. You are an avid gameplayer who must have the latest games and the best hardware.
  3. You're a tinkerer: you like to fiddle with your computer, and to upgrade it, and to mess with Linux, etc.
In these cases, stick with a PC. In all other instances, you ought to consider a Macintosh.


Jeff and I are going to take a closer look at the Mac mini. Apple has a nice subsite devoted to the machine, and we're hoping it will answer some questions. Questions like: with only two USB ports, how does Jeff hook up a printer? Is it possible to purchase a parallel-to-USB converter so that Jeff can use his old printer? Will the Mac mini work with any USB keyboard?

At this point, though, it seems likely that my Mac zealotry will yield its first fruit, that my brother will join the cult.

On this day at foldedspace.org

2004The Decemberists   While browsing various year-end best lists, I kept finding an album called Her Majesty The Decemberists by The Decemberists. A search of the iTunes Music Store yielded said album, and a casual listen of the sample clips was promising, so I downloaded it. But I didn't listen to it. Last night as I set up my new G5, I chose to listen to the Decemberists on a whim. My god! Here is music so perfect it made me cry.

2003Forgotten English   For a few months, the Mirons were saving their Forgotten English pages for me. At some point I decided to write a short story using these words (in chronological order based on the date each appeared in the calendar). I didn't get far.

2002My web sites are back!   My web sites are back! My web sites are back!

Comments
On 14 January 2005 (11:07 AM), Jeff said:

That stinkin' computer is lucky that only the keyboard was harmed, as I wanted to break it all into a thousand little pieces. The keyboard actually still works -- it just wabbles a little now.

After spending 3 hours with the DSL tech getting my service running properly (his help was top-notch, by the way), followed by multiple pop-ups and crashes, followed by another 2 hours of downloading Windows & Internet Explorer updates and adware removers, etc.; I was more than just a little upset with that dumb old HP when it crashed for good.

I guess after 6-1/2 years with the same computer, it is time to upgrade. I did add more RAM and a 16MB graphics card years ago, but the continual problems with all Microsoft products made it a real pain to use. That is why I am going to give Mac a try this time. For all that we use a computer for at home, the Mini will be more than adequate -- especially if I can use it for more than half-an-hour at a time without it crashing.

Adios Bill Gates. Hola Steve Jobs.


On 14 January 2005 (11:20 AM), Jeremy said:

Way to go Jeff. I don not believe you will be sorry!!!

-jeremy

PS. If you need some kid games for Mac you can depend on us!!


On 14 January 2005 (11:32 AM), Dave said:

The easiest thing to do to expand your USB ports is to buy a USB hub (another $20 at Fry's). The only thing that you have to worry about with something like that is overloading the power draw for the port (in which case you can get a powered USB hub) but for keyboard, mouse and printer (which will not be drawing power from the computer anyway), the power draw is minimal. A separate CD or HDD that doesn't have it's own power supply might put too much draw on the port with all the other things, but that would probably be it.

I'd seriously consider the Mac Mini if I were looking to start over in the computer world. As it stands I'm too committed to working on the PC side because of work, but you're right, JD. The problems and complexities with the Windows platform are beginning to crack Microsoft's hold on the OS.


On 14 January 2005 (05:33 PM), dowingba said:

JD, the question is, how feasible is it to take apart your mac mini and exchange components? To order one with upgraded RAM costs twice the price of the default model. While I haven't researched this new product much, I have a sneaking suspicion that, like other Apple products like the iPod, it's damn near impossible to take apart, let alone modify once it's apart. In fact, an Apple spokesman on TV, when asked about this, said merely, "Apple does not recommend you take this machine apart."

Dave, do you have a keyboard and/or mouse that plugs into the wall?


On 15 January 2005 (06:45 AM), Andrew Parker said:

I had the privilege of seeing Mr. Jobs's keynote on Tuesday from the Good Seats -- even got to give my $0.02 to local news channel 5 on the way out. (Coffee appears to be no less expensive for my having done this.)

The iMac Mini is a line extension targeting folks who have resisted Apple's premium prices, drawn in by the lure of some very promising, reasonably-priced, and powerful applications (iLife, iWork, GarageBand). Apple may win this gambit if those new customers don't expect to see the stage from the top rows of the bleachers... So if you're a PC person (like me) who's looked on a computer with lust in your heart, I think you have to not kid yourself and just go G5. If you want a frustrating computer experience, well, don't you already have that?

(I'll wait for Tiger before ordering mine.)


On 15 January 2005 (09:46 AM), Nikchick said:

I've been beating our Blue & White G3 to death for years now. Chris bought it used from a co-worker when he worked at Wizards of the Coast. I already use a generic bought-separately monitor, I long ago expanded my USB capabilities with a hub. I have an external firewire hard drive that is bigger than the hard drive that came with the computer for additional storage.

The Mac mini sounds great to me, for what I do (even for the business) is mostly e-mail, web access, reviewing PDF documents and burning CDs (and, of course, iTunes).

Chris has upgraded with a new PC three times since we started the company, each time for less than $1000, usually closer to $600-$700. I've continued to work on the G3 and my perfectly decent Pismo. My affection for Mac has kept me from switching over to PC upgrades myself, but the price of the new topline Macs is just more than I can justify considering what I use the computers for. The Mac mini is going to go a long way toward keeping me a Mac user for a while longer.


On 17 January 2005 (08:41 AM), Jeff said:

Our computer needs at home are very basic.

Our existing 300 Mhz AMD-K2 would still be adequate for our needs if it didn't keep crashing on us (not just Win98; but Word, Publisher, Internet Explorer, etc, etc.) -- I reinstalled the operating system for the fourth time yesterday. The only exception would be the need to up our hard drive from 4 gigs (digital photos take up a bit of space).

I don't have time to play video games anymore, so I don't need a gaming machine. I have no interest in taking a computer apart tweaking things (if I ever need to upgrade to 1GB of RAM, I can do that easy enough with the Mini).

I kept my crappy HP for 6+ years because a new computer is not something I want to be spending money on every other year -- and I expect to get at leat the same out of the Mini. So, here is what I ordered:

(1) Mac Mini - 1.25Ghz w/ 512MB RAM ----> $574
(1) Mac Keyboard -----------------------------------> $ 29
(1) Epson printer (w/ $99.95 rebate) --------> Free

That leaves the purchase of a USB mouse (~$12) and possibly a USB hub to complete the system (but as small as this thing is, it will be easy enough to just swap out USB cables if I want to plug in my camera). Now I just have to wait a few weeks for it to get here...

As JD said before, the Mini is not for everyone -- it is kind of a niche-market machine -- and I happen to fall into that niche.


On 17 January 2005 (11:10 AM), Jeff said:

One little note -- the Apple Keyboard I ordered has two USB ports built in. No hub needed for me. :-)


On 17 January 2005 (04:09 PM), John Bodoni said:

When I first saw OS X, I knew that it was time for me to re-enter the Macintosh world after leaving the employ of an Apple dealership 10 years ago. I picked up a dual-USB iBook and have loved it.

To give you an idea how long I lived in the Apple worlds, consider: somewhere in my computer room under a stack of stuff I've got my old LC, and my parents might still have my old Apple //c somewhere in their basement, keeping their old IBM PC company.

To me, the Mini is somewhat reminiscent of the old IIcx and IIci computers. I thought that the IIcx was Apple's best computer as far as modularity was concerned.

I'm having serious thoughts about picking up a Mini. The (relatively) small hard drive of the $499 model doesn't bother me as much as the small RAM footprint... after all, I've already got a server on my home network with enough hard drive space to store whatever I don't want on the Mini's boot disk.

Keyboard and mouse? Bluetooth, baby - no wires! How sweet would that be?

Think I'd have to wait until after the divorce to be able to afford one, though.


On 17 January 2005 (07:38 PM), dowingba said:

What's up with the prices for the options? 512mb RAM -- $75. Reasonable. 1gb RAM -- $425. !!?


On 25 January 2005 (08:08 AM), Jeff said:

The world will have one more Mac owner by the end of the day. That's right, my Mini arrives today baby! Now, if I can only sneak this 19" monitor home (to replace my piddly 14 incher) without JD noticing...


Post a comment
Name


Email Address
(required, not shown)


URL


Comments




Remember info?